Why Choosing a Great Book Feels So Hard
I’ve written before about the anxiety of picking the right book to read. The Great Books felt daunting. Too highbrow, too difficult. That’s what I thought. Now that I have read them, has that feeling gone away?
Never.
I look at another Great Book still on my list, and the same old thought surfaces: oh geez, what a slog this is going to be. That’s exactly how I felt recently about Mrs. Dalloway, which I read for a book club.
It’s only 166 pages, and yet I’d open it, read a few pages, and put it back down. Then I’d open it again, read a few more pages, and put it down again. I did this for a month until I finally forced myself to finish it. Boy, am I glad I did.
I think it’s a book for adults of a certain age, people who’ve lived long enough to look back on their past and see things differently. It’s about regrets and the stories we tell ourselves about what happened.
Consider the title: Mrs. Dalloway, not Clarissa. Why is her married name, rather than her given name, the title of the book? What is Woolf saying by that choice? Why is Clarissa so consumed with throwing a party in postwar England, yet unable to deal with the people and memories that trouble her?
I ended up loving Mrs. Dalloway. But I never would experienced Clarissa’s story if I hadn’t picked up the book and pushed through.
I know there are a lot of readers out there who are genuinely unsure whether they’re picking the “right” book. I want to calm that fear and help people see that the Great Books aren’t just books for the top shelf in the living room. They’re books to be read.
“In the case of good books, the point is not to see how many of them you can get through, but rather how many can get through to you.”
— Mortimer J. Adler


